Reality star Heidi Montag was the first to strip off her clothes to pose for the September 2009 issue of Playboy Magazine. Despite Heidi and her husband Spencer Pratt’s efforts to promote the spread, it just wasn’t good enough and she wasn’t even really naked… just dirty and extremely Photoshopped.

Actress Tara Reid followed Heidi’s steps and is the cover girl for the January/February 2010 special double issue of Playboy. Tara promised to show all and prove her body is not disfigured, but the end result was a disappointing topless and extra Photoshopped photo spread.

Tara Reid and Heidi Montag’s nude Playboy photo shoots must have been the most overrated in the famous men’s magazine history. It was not even close to what we expected from both of these girls. The question now is: were they hot in the photos? Absolutely! But who’s hotter?

More On Tara Reid & Heidi Montag Playboy Spreads Below

Heidi Montag Playboy
Heidi Montag Gets Nude For Playboy (Photos)
Heidi Montag Playboy Pics
Heidi Montag Actually NOT Naked in Playboy

Tara Reid Playboy
Tara Reid Gets Nude For Playboy (Photos)
Tara Reid Nude Playboy Photo Spread FIRST PICTURES!
Tara Reid Playboy Cover (January/February 2010)
Tara Reid Wants You To See Her Naked Playboy Spread (VIDEO)
Tara Reid Exclusive Playboy Pictures (NSFW Photos)